Top Rated Crib Mattresses Reviewed and Tested in 2020

Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress

There are three most important things sleeping surface for a baby should be – safe, comfortable, and supportive. This mattress will provide you with exactly that, and as a plus, there is a waterproof cover on top of that.

Features:

  • Affordable price
  • 100% waterproof cover
  • Breathable and safe

Newborn babies are spending most of their time in a crib, sleeping. Because of that, as well as the fact they are extremely fragile and sensitive in this stage of life, it’s crucial that you provide them with the best possible support and safest bed surface there is.

Reputable pediatricians are even claiming that sleep is the most important thing for a baby’s development, so we suggest you take some time for researching and carefully decide which one is the best crib mattress for your infant.

Although the government set the rules regarding its size and thickness, you still have plenty of choices regarding the material they are made of, their breathability, firmness, temperature regulation option, and some other features.

Check out our list of top nine crib mattresses that will make sure the little creatures sleep through the night peacefully and wake up every morning well-rested.

RANK PICTURE NAME RATING SHOP PRODUCT NAME RATING/SHOP
#1 Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress

Show More

99
Check Price
Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress

Show More

99
Check Price

Materials Quality

98%

Comfort

99%

Durability

99%

Price

97%

Check Price
#2 Newton Crib Mattress

Show More

96
Check Price
Newton Crib Mattress

Show More

96
Check Price

Materials Quality

95%

Comfort

97%

Durability

95%

Price

97%

Check Price
#3 Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic

Show More

95
Check Price
Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic

Show More

95
Check Price

Materials Quality

96%

Comfort

94%

Durability

95%

Price

95%

Check Price
#4 Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress

Show More

90
Check Price
Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress

Show More

90
Check Price

Materials Quality

92%

Comfort

90%

Durability

89%

Price

89%

Check Price
#5 Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress

Show More

87
Check Price
Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress

Show More

87
Check Price

Materials Quality

89%

Comfort

87%

Durability

87%

Price

83%

Check Price
#6 Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Show More

84
Check Price
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Show More

84
Check Price

Materials Quality

86%

Comfort

84%

Durability

86%

Price

82%

Check Price
#7 Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress

Show More

82
Check Price
Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress

Show More

82
Check Price

Materials Quality

82%

Comfort

81%

Durability

82%

Price

83%

Check Price
#8 Safety 1st Transitions Baby and Toddler Mattress

Show More

80
Check Price
Safety 1st Transitions Baby and Toddler Mattress

Show More

80
Check Price

Materials Quality

82%

Comfort

78%

Durability

80%

Price

80%

Check Price
#9 Sealy Soybean Natural Dream Crib Mattress

Show More

78
Check Price
Sealy Soybean Natural Dream Crib Mattress

Show More

78
Check Price

Materials Quality

78%

Comfort

77%

Durability

77%

Price

80%

Check Price

Highly Rated Crib Mattress Reviews

98

Materials Quality

99

Comfort

99

Durability

97

Price

Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress

With their unique formula and a specific blend of foam, this hypoallergenic baby sleep surface will provide little ones with a safe and cozy place for all those hours they spend lying down and wandering the realm of dreams. Given they are quite affordable, you can now say goodbye to all those and low-quality synthetic blends and uncomfortable spring mattresses.

The manufacturer used CertiPur certified foam for creating this crib mattress, the one that is recommended for safety reasons by experts. This product, suitable for infants, toddlers, and babies of all ages, will give them a comfortable, supportive base. It will be pleasant, but not too soft, thanks to the high-density foundation that will not lose shape so they won’t sink in.

It’s made in a standard size, so it will fit any regular crib, and the best part is that the mattress is covered with a 100 percent waterproof fabric that will protect it from any kind of spills or leaks. Newly moms will love it since it’s quite easy to clean, you just need to wipe it, and it won’t wrinkle while the baby is sleeping in the crib.

Although the reinforced encasement is protected from wetting on the top and sides, it allows the mattress to breathe. The fiberglass base on the inside is aligned with the federal fire safety requirements, and the product is examined and analyzed so that it meets all necessary standards. This best crib mattress will come to your doorstep packed and rolled in a box, and it will take around 72 hours for it to expand fully.

Show More >>

Highlights

  • Waterproof cover
  • Comfortable and safe
  • Standard size
  • Unique foam formula
  • Breathable
Check Price
Full review

95

Materials Quality

97

Comfort

95

Durability

97

Price

Newton Crib Mattress

If you aren’t interested in saving money by any cost on this subject, we present you with the Newton Baby Crib mattress that has an innovative and reliable breathable technology. Given that breathability is one of the most significant features of this product, they made sure the construction of the mattress allows air to circulate while the little one is asleep. The manufacturer claims it reduces the risk of suffocation during the night.

This particular sleep surface for babies won a couple of awards in previous years because it was recognized as a safe place for newborns and toddlers. It won Mom’s Choice Award, Family Choice Award, and GREENGUARD certificate as a product with low chemical emissions

It’s breathable and lowers the risks of SIDS, and the temperature regulation made sure it doesn’t overheat. Babies won’t have sweaty back anymore, and therefore their resting time will be high-quality. This sleeping surface is designed in a way that’s adequate for infants, but also for older babies who are still spending the night in a crib.

It’s easy to maintain since the cover can be stripped down and put in a washing machine. Without the latex, foam, or adhesives, it’s hypoallergenic and exempt from off-gassing. Just as it should be, this baby crib mattress is created as a perfect combination of comfort and firmness that will give them much needed support.

Show More >>

Highlights

  • Award-winning mattress
  • New breath-thru technology
  • Temperature regulation
  • Washable cover
  • For newborns and toddlers
Check Price
Full review

96

Materials Quality

94

Comfort

95

Durability

95

Price

Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic

This is a memory foam mattress that will provide your little one with restless sleep and great support, a surface that will be a perfect addition to the warm and cozy baby nest. It has a firm base and luxurious layer of high-quality foam, so the child will have the firm ground to lay down on, which won’t change its shape no matter what.

Besides that, this mattress for crib contains removable and washable bamboo cover that is waterproof, extremely soft, and gentle to baby’s skin, as well as very easy for maintenance. There is no way this crib surface will soak in any kind of leaks, so that particular worry can be removed from the list of your concerns.

The product is designed and created in a way that allows air to circulate through its layers, and that way helps the temperature regulation, which is essential for healthy sleep time little ones need at this stage the most. It also has the ability to create balance regarding the weight distribution, which guarantees its durability.

Milliard Premium mattress contains Certi-Pur certified hypoallergenic foam that resists mold, allergens, bacteria, and dust mites – a benefit each baby mattress should have, but the most important one for those children who have allergies or problems with asthma. There aren’t any kind of chemicals, and all the materials are safe and non-toxic.

Show More >>

Highlights

  • Organic bamboo cover
  • High-quality foam
  • Temperature regulation
  • Breathable and safe
  • Firm and durable
Check Price
Full review

92

Materials Quality

90

Comfort

89

Durability

89

Price

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress

Here is another great option if you are searching for the crib mattress. It’s an orthopedic and lightweight 6 inches thick sleeping surface designed for standard baby bed with extra firm sides, great for all infant’s needs. We are talking about the super firm and supportive product that will help an infant’s development and provide him with a good night’s rest.

This is an eco-friendly and breathable mattress with an ultra-soft waterproof cover. Babies will feel cozy and protected while lying on organic cotton fabric, which will always stay dry, no matter what. The mattress is alignment with all safety standards. It’s CertiPUR-US certified and has GREENGUARD Gold patch that proves it has no harmful emissions.

Dual firmness is one of the best selling baby crib mattresses on the market today, given you can use one side when your child is a newborn, and the other when he transitions into the toddler stage. Infants need very firm, even surface with high resistance in order to bring the strength to their muscles, while a bit older kids can enjoy in the softer ground, more comfortable and snuggly.

Since it can be used on both sides, the item is very durable, and it will last you long enough until your kid doesn’t get the proper size bed and leaves the crib behind him. All Colgate Crib mattresses are made in the US with eco foam that is infused with plant oils.

Show More >>

Highlights

  • Dual-use
  • Firm and durable
  • Orthopedic
  • Breathable
  • Organic cotton cover
Check Price
Full review

89

Materials Quality

87

Comfort

87

Durability

83

Price

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress

It seems like the dual type of mattresses is the best choice for the crib. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer will support your infant with an eco-friendly and extra firm side, but it will also be a soft plush surface for your toddler to sleep on. This one, in particular, is filled with plant-based foam, which will provide the little ones with safe, durable, and high-quality surroundings.

It’s covered with easy to clean, waterproof medical grade fabric that doesn’t contain toxic flame-retardant chemicals. It’s also hypoallergenic, dust mite and bed bug resistant, which is essential in this stage of baby’s life. Regarding the maintenance, you can simply use a cloth or damp sponge to wipe away any kind of a wet mess.

The manufacturer says the product went through demanding testing procedures to establish excellent breathability, adequate firmness, great safety, and necessary performance. It’s free from indoor air polluting, so it won’t leave a toxic scent in your nursery.

Many parents are swearing that Moonlight Slumber mattresses for kids are some of the best and safest in their category, created with advanced health and safety features, in a way to make sure the babies will have everything they need while resting. They are made in the U.S, with domestic materials, and are GREENGUARD and CertiPUR Certified.

Show More >>

Highlights

  • Dual-use
  • Medical grade fabric
  • Waterproof
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Safe and durable
Check Price
Full review

86

Materials Quality

84

Comfort

86

Durability

82

Price

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

As the title of the crib mattress says, this is an absolutely safe choice for your baby to sleep on. The brand received the Women’s Choice Award in a category America’s Most Recommended brand for Baby Crib & Toddler Mattress. It’s very durable and high-quality made, with high-density thermo-bonded fiber core, which will provide excellent support for newborns.

The dimensions of the product are in accordance with all regulations and standard sized cribs, and the weight limit is 50 pounds. In order to preserve its condition, you should rotate it every couple of months. The mattress comes with a 10-year warranty and has a 100 percent Vinyl waterproof cover.

With this hypoallergenic sleeping surface beneath them, babies will go through the whole night without waking up or crying in a cozy but supportive surrounding. This is another GREENGUARD Gold certified product that’s free of lead and phthalates, with low chemical emissions into indoor air. 

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams crib mattress is lightweight, so you won’t have a problem while maneuvering with it, and it’s appropriate for both newborns and toddlers. The manufacturer is offering great selection in this category, so you just need to pick the one you believe will be the perfect fit for your little one.

Show More >>

Highlights

  • Lightweight
  • Vinyl cover
  • Supportive and firm
  • Award-winning
  • 10-year warranty
Check Price
Full review

82

Materials Quality

81

Comfort

82

Durability

83

Price

Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress

We present you an innerspring mattress for infants and toddlers, the one with high coil quality and number, which will provide the little ones the good night’s rest. Heat-tempered interwoven steel coil base of this crib mattress will bring the excellent firmness and posture support. It will keep the edges still and steady so that the baby can get an adequate orthopedic lining.

The antibacterial cover that found its place at the top is breathable and, therefore, safe for. It’s very easy to clean, given it demands just to be wiped with a damp cloth, and it guarantees more sanitary sleeping surface for infants. The crib mattress is quality-tested and is proven to be firm, durable, and fit for standard sized cribs. 

The product is intended for kids up to four years old and has an anti-sag weight distribution system, so their lifespan will be long and lasting. There are a couple of layers of comfortable and soft cushioning on each side that will allow air to circulate in continuity. 

The manufacturer is proudly underlining their achievements and awards their product has won, as well as the fact that more babies sleep on this mattress than on any other one in the USA. They are free of all flame retardant chemicals and have a lifetime warranty on materials as well as on workmanship.

Show More >>

Highlights

  • Firm and supportive
  • Breathable antibacterial cover
  • Anti-sag weight distribution
  • Award-winning
  • Lifetime warranty
Check Price
Full review

82

Materials Quality

78

Comfort

80

Durability

80

Price

Safety 1st Transitions Baby and Toddler Mattress

One of the most affordable mattresses for babies is this Safety 1st Transitions Baby and Toddler sleeping surface that’s made from polyester fibers, with a high-density thermo-bonded base. It will turn the baby’s nap area into the perfect cozy, but a firm place with great support.

The brand that stands behind this product has received the 2020 Women’s Choice Award in the category of America’s Most Recommended brand for Crib & Toddler Mattress. That means that parents all around the U.S tried it and confirmed that the item could provide what the manufacturer promised.

This sleeping surface is excellent in so many ways, but the fact it has a dual purpose is probably the best one yet. When the baby is a newborn, you should use one side of it, the one that’s firmer, since that’s what the infants need in order to develop properly. But when a baby gets to be a toddler, then you can flip it and let him sleep on a more comfortable and soft side. 

The item is lightweight, very durable, which is crucial since you plan to use it for a couple of years and has a non-removable cover that is water-resistant. You can simply clean it with a mop. Also, you should know that it will fit in every standard size crib.

Show More >>

Highlights

  • Non-removable waterproof cover
  • Affordable price
  • Dual purpose
  • Lightweight and durable
  • Provides great support
Check Price
Full review

78

Materials Quality

77

Comfort

77

Durability

80

Price

Sealy Soybean Natural Dream Crib Mattress

When we think about our little ones, we know the most important thing is for them to remain safe. Therefore here is a baby crib mattress that’s breathable, supportive, and CertiPur-US approved. With high-density soybean foam, it’s created to be lightweight but firm, just as it should be, according to the pediatricians.

The soy-based core is proven to be great since it will give the item a longer lifespan, especially if you compare it to the conventional foam mattresses. This durable object has a plush cotton cover that’s moisture, water, and stain-resistant, and it’s offering a cooler and softer bed surface with natural woven fibers.

The hypoallergenic layer is a great support for newly born babies regarding their development and need for fresh air, while soybean foam prevents sagging and guarantees the best comfort for the little ones. The airflow keeps the item fresh, while the waterproof layer helps to protect the baby from mildew, mold, and any odors.

It has standard crib mattress size, so it will fit into almost every crib, and the great thing is that you won’t have to change it when your baby gets older, given it’s appropriate for toddlers too. The mattress is free from flame retardant chemicals and comes from an award-winning brand many parents are swearing by. It comes with a lifetime warranty on materials and workmanship.

Show More >>

Highlights

  • Lightweight design
  • Very durable
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Water-resistant
  • Lifetime warranty
Check Price
Full review

Crib Mattresses Buyer’s Guide

There are a couple of things you should have in mind when buying a new mattress for cribs. But two of them are a top priority. First of all, remember that sleep is one of the most important things for your baby’s development, so the surface she is lying on should be firm, supportive, and breathable in order to provide with everything baby needs at this stage.

Second of all, make sure the product your kid is going to spend a lot of time on is completely safe, that its perfect size, without gaps that can pose a danger to the little one, and that it’s high-quality made, from good, natural materials which won’t prevent baby’s skin from breathing. 

The best thing is that you don’t have to spend an enormous amount of money in order to get your child’s sleeping booth properly arranged. Let’s check what features you should be looking for when choosing the perfect crib mattress for your little ones.

What Should You Look For in a Crib Mattress?

You really shouldn’t try to save money when purchasing a baby mattress. The statistics are saying that average infants spend around 18 hours a day sleeping in a crib. So just try to find the best one possible, according to your capabilities and budget.

It’s necessary to make sure the mattress fits the crib you posses, and that’s preferably made out of natural and breathable materials. Pediatricians agree that a newborn’s sleeping surface should be very firm because it gives them the best support and prevents the risk of suffocation, which is one of the most common reasons for sudden infant death.

Also, the baby crib mattress where your little ones will lay on should be hypoallergenic and free from all kinds of toxins. Search for those that are CertiPur-US approved and aligned with all necessary safety standards. Those that have a dual purpose – one side for infants and another for toddlers are proven to be very useful and practical.

Materials

Some experts say that the top layer of mattress should be made out of natural and organic materials since the baby will have direct contact with that particular fabric, but those mattresses usually aren’t waterproof. In that case, make sure to check there are no wet spots on the mattress and that your child is not sleeping on the soggy surface. The ones that are water-resistant are created with vinyl or polyethylene, which is also fine if they are breathable, but be positive they don’t have phthalates or plasticizers, which can be harmful to little ones.

Firmness

This is probably the most important aspect regarding the subject of sleeping surfaces for infants. Research has shown that soft mattresses increase the risk of SIDS. The structure that provides them with the soft and cozy ground can make them sink too much and sometimes suffocate. The best option for newborns is a very firm and supportive mattress that won’t dent under their weight. Those with the softer structure are suitable for toddlers who can turn and control their movement. Pretty often, manufacturers are offering dual function crib mattresses that can be flipped, and have one side for infants and another for a bit older kids.

Size

Most of the mattresses for cribs are made to fit the standard crib. The federal government regulated this matter via the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008 and said what the required dimensions of sleeping surfaces for babies are. The minimum size is 27 ¼ inches x 51 5/8 inches, and they shouldn’t be thicker than 6 inches. So that part is non-negotiable, although there is some tolerance regarding their interior dimension. But you can choose between different types of mattresses, and make sure all other features are in accordance with your wishes.

Compliance Standards

When thinking about how crucial all those safety issues are, we have to admit it’s quite soothing to know the mattress you would like to purchase is certified in those specific areas and alliance with all necessary standards. It should have a GREENGUARD Gold certificate for minimal emissions of volatile organic compounds, as well as CertiPUR-US certificate, which implies it’s free of formaldehyde or lead. Those particular products that have –„organic” label need to possess the Global Organic Textile Standard credentials.

Ease of Cleaning and Resisting Stains

Every busy mother prefers products that are easy to wash and maintain, simply because she doesn’t have the time to waste. The new baby in the house will occupy all her attention, so the possibility of having a mattress that’s not demanding in a field of maintenance is just fulfilling. There are plenty of sleeping surfaces with covers that are water-resistant and, therefore, stainless. All you have to do in order to keep the mattress clean is to wipe the surface with a damp sponge or a mop, and that’s it. Without the fuss, your precious time is saved enormously.

Different Types of Crib Mattresses

Foam

If the mattress is made out of polyurethane foam, it’s probably very lightweight, more than others. Some parents tend to be worried since sleeping surfaces made out of foam are mostly medium-firm, and infants need that level to be higher to prevent any kind of danger while sleeping. They are the most affordable choice if compared to other types of crib surfaces, but the density needs to be great for them to provide proper support. Another thing is good to know – these kinds of mattresses make almost no noise when the little ones are moving around during the night.

Innerspring

When talking about these types of mattresses, one thing is for sure – they have steel coils in the support core and one soft layer of cotton or foam at the top. Given a bunch of metal parts are lying at the bottom of it, the mattress is mostly pretty heavy. It weights from 15 to 20 pounds on average. Most of them are firm enough to be an infant’s sanctuary, and besides that, these kinds of mattresses will provide their little bodies with great support. Their big advantage is the fact they have great durability and a longer lifespan than the others.

Organic

Organic mattresses are mostly foam ones, but there are innerspring models also available in the market. These kinds of sleeping surfaces suppose to have the Global Organic Textile Standard, but it’s essential that you know that they are not really 100 percent organic. This certificate guarantees they are at least 70 percent made of organic materials, while the rest can be from any other compound. Despite that, they are the most expensive in the market – the average price goes somewhere between $150 and $200. But you should also know that they produce minimal noise and can have a medium or firm feel.

Dual-Sided Mattresses

Parents are crazy for this type of baby crib mattress because they are practical, durable, and save them a lot of money. They are created as two separate mattresses, with different features, combined in one item. If you put it on one side, it will be super firm and with great support – perfect for a newborn. But when you flip it to another side you will discover its extra soft and snuggly – ideal for a toddler who moves around a lot during sleep. With this crib mattress, you will basically get two for the price of one.

FAQ

Q: How to know if the crib mattress is firm enough?

To test the mattress for a crib, you are thinking of buying, to check if it’s firm enough for a newborn, press it hard with the hand, in the center, and at the edges. There shouldn’t be any dent or mark of your hand on it, and the mattress should snap back right away.

Q: How much should I spend on a crib mattress?

The average price of a crib mattress is somewhere between $70 and $200. In that price range, there are many options regarding the mattress type, as well as all those different features, including some warranties. The most expensive are the ones that are called organic, while the innerspring and foam sleeping surfaces are competitive.

Q: Are foam crib mattresses safe for babies?

If you have a newborn, look for a high-density firm foam mattress, or coil one that has at least 150 coils. A best baby crib mattress needs to be extremely firm in order for them to stay safe, and to lower the risk of suffocation. You should use foam mattress mostly for toddlers and older kids.

Conclusion

The quest for the best crib mattress is no joke. There are a bunch of things to consider and a couple of topics to research before deciding which one is ideal for your baby. So try to absorb all these suggestions and advice because we made sure to put the safety of the little ones on top of our priority list. The most important feature your crib surface should have is high firmness level, but it also must be breathable. Your baby needs to be in the safest surroundings possible to grow and develop properly. We know the price is always an issue, but this time you have to go beyond that point and think only about the fact that kids spend most of their time lying on this particular object.

Scroll Up