Highly Rated Innerspring Mattresses in 2019

Last Updated on by My Sleep Bot

Despite all the hype for memory foam mattresses, many people still prefer good old-fashioned innerspring models. Using coils, these mattresses are very responsive, durable, and supportive. Moreover, they’re more affordable than their memory foam counterparts.

Customers often struggle to choose an innerspring mattress that will work for them. This is due to the high number of available brands and models. There are many sizes and styles out there, and it can be quite challenging to find the right type for your needs. To make matters even more confusing, many of these beds are not entirely innerspring products. They often incorporate some materials found in different types of mattresses. 

To make things easier for you, we’ve decided to analyze the market’s top models in detail. We picked the most popular innerspring mattresses, coming from reputable brands. By making a quick overview of each model, we tried to outline its most significant advantages. We’ve also compiled a convenient buyer’s guide, consisting of all that you need to know about these products.

Beautyrest BR800 12 Inch Innerspring Mattress

As it checks all the boxes, the Beautyrest BR00 is the best innerspring mattress we’ve analyzed. It has a sleek, modern design, and offers things like excellent comfort, motion isolation, and airflow.

Features:

  • Pocketed coil technology – excellent support and movement diffusion
  • AirCool foam for peaceful, undisturbed rest 
  • Antimicrobial performance layer keeps the bed fresh and cool

Our 9 Top Rated Innerspring Mattress

RANK PICTURE NAME RATING SHOP PRODUCT NAME RATING/SHOP
#1 Linenspa 8 Inch Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid Mattress

Show More

99
Check Price
Linenspa 8 Inch Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid Mattress

Show More

99
Check Price

Materials Quality

98%

Comfort

99%

Durability

99%

Price

97%

Check Price
#2 Beautyrest BR800 12 Inch Innerspring Mattress

Show More

97
Check Price
Beautyrest BR800 12 Inch Innerspring Mattress

Show More

97
Check Price

Materials Quality

97%

Comfort

98%

Durability

96%

Price

96%

Check Price
#3 Linenspa 6 Inch Innerspring Mattress

Show More

94
Check Price
Linenspa 6 Inch Innerspring Mattress

Show More

94
Check Price

Materials Quality

92%

Comfort

97%

Durability

92%

Price

92%

Check Price
#4 Olee Sleep 10 Inch Cool I-Gel Innerspring Mattress

Show More

91
Check Price
Olee Sleep 10 Inch Cool I-Gel Innerspring Mattress

Show More

91
Check Price

Materials Quality

91%

Comfort

89%

Durability

93%

Price

89%

Check Price
#5 Dreamfoam Unwind Innerspring Mattress

Show More

88
Check Price
Dreamfoam Unwind Innerspring Mattress

Show More

88
Check Price

Materials Quality

88%

Comfort

88%

Durability

89%

Price

87%

Check Price
#6 Dreamtale 8 Inch Multi-Layer Innerspring Mattress

Show More

85
Check Price
Dreamtale 8 Inch Multi-Layer Innerspring Mattress

Show More

85
Check Price

Materials Quality

87%

Comfort

85%

Durability

87%

Price

83%

Check Price
#7 Rucas Innerspring Mattress

Show More

84
Check Price
Rucas Innerspring Mattress

Show More

84
Check Price

Materials Quality

84%

Comfort

87%

Durability

82%

Price

84%

Check Price
#8 Inofia 12 Inch Innerspring Mattress

Show More

81
Check Price
Inofia 12 Inch Innerspring Mattress

Show More

81
Check Price

Materials Quality

81%

Comfort

86%

Durability

78%

Price

81%

Check Price
#9 Modern Sleep Advantage Innerspring 8-Inch Mattress

Show More

78
Check Price
Modern Sleep Advantage Innerspring 8-Inch Mattress

Show More

78
Check Price

Materials Quality

84%

Comfort

78%

Durability

74%

Price

80%

Check Price

Linenspa 8 Inch Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid Mattress

Highlights

  • Lightweight – easy to set up and move
  • Provides reliable support & pressure relief 
  • Spring coils improve breathability 
  • Affordable price 
  • 10-year warranty 

Materials Quality

98

Comfort

99

Durability

99

Price

97

Affordable but reliable, Linenspa is undoubtedly one of the top names in the game. Their 8-inch Innerspring Hybrid Mattress seems to be a popular choice. For that matter, it deserves a more in-depth look. 

Linenspa 8-Inch features just two layers of tempered steel coils and poly-foam. As such, this model sports one of the simplest hybrid designs on the market.  The materials used in its manufacture create a pressure-relieving sleeping experience. The no-fuss construction, on the other hand, keeps the price tag on the lower end. 

Its support layer, comprised of 6.5″ steel coils, is the primary support system of the model. The temperature regulation is encouraged by the spaces between the coils. Moreover, this section also brings some bounce to the entire structure. The open coil design of this mattress is very similar to the ones found in traditional innerspring mattresses. 

The comfort layer is 1.5″ thick and consists of poly-foam. It does not offer a quick response to pressure but provides a satisfying amount of sinkage. The cover is also quilted with some memory foam, offering a degree of immediate pressure relief. It’s very soft to touch, as it was crafted from an exclusive polyester brand. 

All in all, Linenspa 8 provides a beautiful sleeping experience. It successfully combines steel coils with memory foam. It’s an excellent best-value choice and an investment that you won’t regret making.

Show More

Beautyrest BR800 12 Inch Innerspring Mattress

Highlights

  • Modern design 
  • Good at isolating motion
  • Temperature regulation – great for hot sleepers
  • Antimicrobial performance layer 
  • 10-year warranty

Materials Quality

97

Comfort

98

Durability

96

Price

96

The next innerspring mattress in our roundup is a bit more expensive. It sports a few innovative features which put it above the competition. 

The first thing to notice about this model is its sleek, impeccable design. Combining a couple of darker colors, this mattress fits in with the decor of any bedroom. It is available in six different sizes. These are Full, King, Queen, Twin, Twin XL, and California King. 

The primary selling point of BR800 is it pocketed coil technology. It successfully diffuses movement and supports the natural shape of the sleeper’s body. As it provides flexible support exactly where it’s needed, one doesn’t have to worry about motion transfer at all. This makes the model an excellent choice for those with sleeping buddies

Another great thing about BR800 is that it uses patented AirCool foam. This foam sports a channeled design that lets the air flow through the mattress. The result of this is a peaceful, undisturbed rest. Hot sleepers are guaranteed to appreciate this feature

We also liked that this model has a special antimicrobial layer. It’s yet another of its temperature-regulating components. Its job is to keep the bed fresh and cool while you’re sleeping. The 10-year warranty deal inspires confidence in its longevity. 

The Beautyrest BR800 was made to provide its user with the best sleeping experience. It is, undoubtedly, a worthy purchase.

Show More

Linenspa 6 Inch Innerspring Mattress

Highlights

  • Exceptional durability and support 
  • Sturdy heavy-gauge coils
  • Firm but comfortable 
  • Reasonable price 
  • 10-year warranty

Materials Quality

92

Comfort

97

Durability

92

Price

92

The only accurate way to describe this model would be to call it a “hybrid” of sorts. Namely, this model has foam in its construction. This allows it to offer things like excellent back support and firmness. 

The primary layer of this mattress measures 6 inches in thickness. It consists of durable heavy-duty coils. These are capable of withstanding different forces and weights exerted onto it. The inner materials, on the other hand, combine various types of foam. Just as we expected, the cover is made from 100% polyester fabrics

This mattress is an excellent choice for people who look for firmness. Due to its construction and heavy-gauged design, it is extremely supportive. On the other hand, those looking for a plush and soft bed should search elsewhere. The quicksand effect and deep sinking are not present here. It is, after all, a spring mattress.  

No matter the weight of the user, the Linenspa 6-Inch never gets fully compressed. This makes it a perfect choice for people who want a flat surface to sleep on. The price is somewhat reasonable, so you won’t have to break a bank to own this mattress. 

The model arrives compressed and vacuumed. It is available in six different sizes and weighs 67 pounds. A 10-year warranty deal accompanies it. There is also a 30-day money-back guarantee

If you’re searching for a firm but comfortable innerspring model, this mattress might be your best choice.

Show More

Olee Sleep 10 Inch Cool I-Gel Innerspring Mattress

Highlights

  • Conforms to body curves 
  • “Dura” coils provide excellent back support
  • Impressive motion isolation
  • I-Gel layer overcomes heat 
  • CertiPUR-US certified

Materials Quality

91

Comfort

89

Durability

93

Price

89

As the name suggests, the most alluring aspect of this model is its gel layering. This makes it a perfect choice for people who sweat a lot during the night. It provides a cooling essence to one’s body. However, that’s not the only good thing about this model. Let’s check out the rest of its features: 

Like an innerspring mattress in its core, this model features a “Dura” spring base. The continuous coil design promotes back support and undisturbed sleep. The spring base is 7.5″ thick and maintains the firmness that so many consumers are looking for. 

Another advantage of this model’s coils is motion isolation. If your sleeping buddy moves a lot throughout the night, you won’t feel a thing. Along with the equal weight distribution, the mattress conforms to the curves of the sleeper’s body. 

However, the main selling point of this model is its I-Gel layering. This gel reshapes the foam structure and makes it easier to handle high temperatures. It serves as the model’s cooling system. As it keeps the heat at bay, it allows hot sleepers to get a good night’s rest.

Another great thing about this model is that it’s CertiPUR-US certified. You won’t have to worry about dangerous chemicals or emissions. 

For sweaty sleepers, this model is dream-come-true. Consider getting it if you’re struggling with high temperatures during sleep.

Show More

Dreamfoam Unwind Innerspring Mattress

Highlights

  • Accommodates a variety of sleeping positions
  • Innerspring coils provide excellent support
  • Premium foam layer for plush comfort 
  • Increased airflow & breathability 
  • Minimal motion transfer

Materials Quality

88

Comfort

88

Durability

89

Price

87

Although an innerspring model in its core, the Dreamfoam Unwind is actually a hybrid mattress. Its innerspring coils offer pressure relief and support. Furthermore, its memory foam layers provide the necessary comfort. 

The base layer of Dreamfoam Unwind consists of premium innerspring coils and is 6 inches thick. As they individually adjust to one’s curves, these coils provide customized support. Moreover, they ensure minimal motion transfer. In case you’re sharing your bed with a restless sleeper, you’ll find this feature to be invaluable. 

The model’s spring coils give it a medium-firm comfort level. They keep the sleeper’s spine in neutral alignment and allow one to wake up without any aches. Furthermore, they keep the body from sinking into the model’s layers. 

The comfort layer, on the other hand, is 1.5″ thick and consists of premium foam. The purpose of this layer is to mold to one’s body – it conforms to the sleeper’s curves. Once the pressure is removed, no lasting impressions will be left on the surface of this innerspring mattress. 

Another thing we liked about this model is that it can relieve various body aches by preventing pressure points. Its memory foam layer displaces pressure from the typical pain points, such as the neck, hips, and shoulders. There is also a transition layer between the coils and the comfort layer. By reinforcing the coils’ strength, it improves the model’s reliability and durability.

Show More

Dreamtale 8 Inch Multi-Layer Innerspring Mattress

Highlights

  • Very affordable
  • Luxurious design 
  • Multiple layers for premium comfort 
  • Sturdy spring system for ultimate support 
  • Flammability tests passed

Materials Quality

87

Comfort

85

Durability

87

Price

83

Those looking for the best innerspring mattress should also consider Dreamtale’s latest model. Providing a perfect balance of support and comfort, this multi-layered mattress seems to be a worthwhile investment. 

One of the first things to notice about this model is its flawless design. Available in two sizes (King & Queen), the Dreamtale 8-inch sports an eye-catching Italian pattern design. It successfully combines gray with white and easily fits with any bedroom’s decor. 

However, it is the ideal balance between support and balance that sells this model. Like an innerspring mattress, it features a sturdy spring system at its bottom. This system successfully distributes weight and provides the much-needed support for any sleeper, no matter the weight. 

As the name suggests, this model combines different layers of foam to provide the best sleeping experience. These are the low-density and high-density foam layers. While the first one offers more support for one’s body, the second one observes more pressure. Above the multi-layer foam is the cover, made out of luxury knitted jacquard fabric. 

When it comes to dimensions, the Dreamtale 8-Inch measures 80″ x 60″ x 8″ and weighs close to 60 pounds. As it uses fire-resistant cotton, it has passed all the necessary safety and flammability tests. 

For the price it comes at, this model seems to be a good choice for anyone. It’s a comfortable multi-layered innerspring mattress with a sleek look and premium feel – what more could one want?

Show More

Rucas Innerspring Mattress

Highlights

  • Impeccable design
  • Pocket springs isolate motion
  • Comfortable high-density foam 
  • Breathable 3D-knitted cover 
  • 15-year warranty

Materials Quality

84

Comfort

87

Durability

82

Price

84

If your innerspring mattress also needs to have a beautiful design, Rucas’ newest model might be your best choice. This gorgeous beauty of a bed immediately captivates the eye with its look. Fortunately, that’s not the only good thing about it. 

This model combines pocket springs with long-lasting memory foam to provide one with a good night’s rest. As you already know, pocket springs are far better at isolating motion than the coil springs. This is because they work independently from each other – you won’t even notice your partner moving during the night. This makes it a perfect choice for people who have trouble falling asleep. 

When it comes to comfort, Rucas features a layer of high-density foam that minimizes the feel of pocket springs. Proper back support and alignment are guaranteed – we’ve expected nothing less. 

However, the thing we liked the most is the presence of a soft, knit fabric cover. As a smooth, breathable surface, it features a 3D pattern that further enhances the comfort of this mattress. It promotes free airflow – you won’t have to worry about sweaty nights anymore. 

We should also mention that the Rucas Innerspring Mattress is CertiPUR – US Certified for durability. It is accompanied by a 15-Year Guarantee and a 100-night trial period

The sleek look and innovative features of this model put it above the competition. It’s one of the best innerspring-type beds on the market – well-designed, durable, and soothing for all weight and body types.

Show More

Inofia 12 Inch Innerspring Mattress

Highlights

  • Intricate multi-layered design for best comfort 
  • Outstanding body support 
  • Soft & skin-friendly cover 
  • Enhanced airflow 
  • 10-year warranty

Materials Quality

81

Comfort

86

Durability

78

Price

81

When it comes to top innerspring mattresses, it’s hard not to mention Inofia. This company manufactures and sells some of the best bed-related products on the market. These include mattresses, mattress toppers, pillows, etc. Most of their products come with 100-night trial periods and 10-year warranty deals

Their 12-Inch Innerspring Mattress seems to be the product of choice for many people across the country. Beautifully designed and highly functional, it is available in three different sizes. Furthermore, it comes at a relatively affordable price. 

The best thing about this model is its intricate, elaborate design. Inofia 12-Inch consists of six different layers. When combined, they provide the sleeper with all the support and comfort he’ll ever need.

The first of these is the base layer. Located at the very bottom, it’s a high-density foam layer that creates a durable base for the whole mattress. Above it is the collection of individual pocket springs. These all work together to provide outstanding body support and enhanced durability. Moreover, these pocket springs are very good at isolating motion. They turn this bed into an excellent choice for couples. 

Above the springs is the dual-cool fiber layer. Together with the smart-flow layer, it regulates the temperature. Then comes the standard pressure-relieving memory foam. Made out of eco-friendly materials, it offers the necessary body pressure relief. Finally, the top side of the mattress features a cooling-sleep cover. The cover is hypoallergenic and incredibly soft to touch. 

With its elaborate multi-layered design, Inofia 12-Inch is a joy to sleep on

Show More

Modern Sleep Advantage Innerspring 8-Inch Mattress

Highlights

  • Affordable
  • Cushion-firm feel
  • Contours precisely to the user’s body
  • Tempered steel coil system
  • Durable and detailed knit cover

Materials Quality

84

Comfort

78

Durability

74

Price

80

The last spring mattress we’re going to take a look at is also one of the cheapest. Coming at a genuinely affordable price, the Modern Sleep Advantage 8-inch offers several exciting features. 

First of all, this model has a design that makes it look pricier than it actually is. The main reason behind this is the presence of an exquisitely quilt-knitted cover. It has an extremely sleek and modern look. It also provides optimum edge support and durability with its tightly-knitted edges.

When it comes to the construction, the Modern Sleep Advantage 8-Inch sports a tempered-steel coil system. It is the core of the mattress, with the coils contouring to the sleeper’s body to provide undisturbed sleep. As they operate individually of each other, they also reduce the sensation of movement. This makes the model an excellent choice for those with sleeping buddies. 

Don’t let the talk of coils scare you, though – you’ll never feel them thanks to a layer of comfort foam. It gives the model a cushion-firm feel and is both very supportive and reasonably comfortable. Moreover, the edges of this mattress are strong enough to handle the user sitting on them. 

Unlike many other models we’ve analyzed, this one is backed by a much shorter warranty of three years. It is, however, very reasonably priced. Cheap but functional and comfortable, it’s a worthwhile investment.

Show More

Innerspring Mattress Buyer's Guide

Also referred to as spring mattresses, the innerspring mattresses are primarily manufactured using internal coils. Most products of this type consist of three parts: the support layer, the comfort layer, and the fabric cover. To get an innerspring mattress that meets your needs fully, you’ll have to take the quality of these three parts into account. 

Another essential thing to consider is the warranty. Fortunately, most of the reputable brands back their best innerspring mattresses with 10-year warranty deals. Moreover, you’ll have to look for a CertiPUR-US certification. This is particularly important if you’re buying the bed for your child. It’s something that guarantees that your new mattress contains no harmful substances. 

If you have a sleeping buddy, consider getting a model with good motion isolation. Innerspring mattresses with pocket springs are especially good in this regard. Each of these springs acts individually, allowing them to significantly reduce the sensation of movement. This is especially convenient for people with restless sleeping partners. The pocket springs are also more durable and provide better support.

Different Types of Innerspring Mattresses

First developed by a German architect in the 1800s, the innerspring cushioning still dominates the US sales market. However, these types of mattresses now have to compete against newer technologies. These include airbeds, hybrid and latex beds, as well as those filled with memory foam and poly-foam. 

The innerspring construction can still be found in a wide variety of today’s mattresses, though. Around two-thirds of nationwide industry sales are occupied by this style of cushioning. It has endured due to a couple of different factors. Not only is it well-suited for certain types of sleepers, but it’s also the most affordable type. 

It refers to the support core, which typically consists of coils. Today’s best models are distinguished by the type of coils – here are the four primary categories:

  • Pocketed Coils

Also known as encased coils, these come wrapped in cloth and are connected to each other by strands of fabric. However, no additional wire attachments or helicals are used. For that matter, spring mattresses using pocketed coils have the best motion isolation out of all types.

  • Continuous Wire Coils 

These types of coils sport several rows of wires molded into circular shapes. The wires are connected to each other by helicals on both sides. This arrangement isn’t the best when it comes to contouring. However, it provides fantastic resilience and stability.

  • Offset coils

These coils are shaped like hourglasses, manufactured from tempered steel, and connected via helicals. However, the bottom of each offset coil is straightened. This is done to create a hinging effect whenever the mattress is compressed. Mattresses with offset coils are very durable and sometimes quite expensive.

  • Bonnell Coils

Compared to other types of coils, these are more widely available and also cheaper. Bonnell coils are similar to offset coils – they have an hourglass shape and are joined by helicals. However, they’re usually reinforced with low-gauge wires. As they can withstand high levels of compression, they’re typically used by dorms and hotels.

Criteria We Considered

Buying a new innerspring mattress can be exhausting. We’re here to help you out – we’ve rounded up the market’s most popular models and carefully analyzed their features. If you’re interested in the criteria we considered while choosing the best innerspring mattress, keep reading:

  • Comfort & Feel

Above all, your brand new innerspring mattress needs to be as comfortable as possible. Before buying a particular model, make sure to try it out first. Lay down on it and ensure that it doesn’t cause any pressure points on your body. Don’t forget to take breath-ability and cooling into consideration, too.

  • Thickness

Another important factor we considered is the thickness. As you can already guess, the thickness of a particular model mostly depends on which brand you choose. Budget-oriented models are simpler in design and thinner. Your weight is an essential factor. Heavier people need thicker beds for the best comfort. Lighter people don’t – thinner mattresses work for them just as well. 

  • Firmness

If you sleep on your belly or back, you’ll want a medium-firm spring mattress. If you’re a side sleeper, you’ll need a softer bed. Weight is also a vital consideration here. Heavier people require a firmer model. Lighter individuals tend to sleep better on a softer spring mattress.

  • Lifespan & Durability 

What’s the typical lifespan of the model you’d like to purchase? If it’s less than seven years, you might want to change your mind. Despite their lower prices, most innerspring mattresses sold by reputable brands are remarkably durable. Try to obtain a model whose coils are made out of stainless steel.

  • Warranties

Most of the innerspring mattresses we’ve analyzed are backed by 10-year warranty deals. In most cases, a 10-year warranty deal will protect your model from certain defects. These typically include things like manufacturing flaws or excessive sagging. Normal wear and tear, on the other hand, is never covered.

  • Good For?

The best innerspring mattresses are the ones that employ individually wrapped coils. By purchasing one of these, you’ll have a bed that contours to your body straight from the coil level. This ensures less pressure and better support. Moreover, they’re excellent at separating side-to-side motion on the bed.

FAQ

Q: How much does an innerspring mattress cost?

Many individuals choose to go with these types of beds because of their low price. The models employing the newest technologies can cost thousands of dollars. The innerspring-type models can cost less than $100! This makes them a perfect choice for people with tight budgets.

Q: Are innerspring mattresses good for sex?

As they’re typically more responsive, these types of mattresses are well-suited for sex. Many couples appreciate how bouncy these models are, claiming that they’re the best type when it comes to having sex. Memory foam, on the other hand, offers more “sinkage” and doesn’t perform as well.

Q: I often sweat during the night. Should I buy a spring mattress?

If you’re a hot sleeper, the temperature regulation is among the first things you should consider. Thanks to their open construction, the spring mattresses are probably your best choice. They offer excellent temperature regulation and good airflow.

Conclusion

While a traditional choice, innerspring mattresses are still quite popular nowadays. They very affordable, but also provide things like durability, and support. The market offers dozens of brands and models to choose from. To put it simply, it’s all up to your personal needs and preferences. 

To make things easier, you can always consult our reviews and the buying guide. We’ve analyzed the market’s most popular models and created a short but comprehensive buyer’s guide. Hopefully, these will be of some help to you, and you’ll end up with the best innerspring mattress that will serve you for the years to come.